Society Central

I have a group of 4 ladies celebrating their 60th birthdays next January. They want a property that has 2 bedrooms with a living room and kitchen but either on or close to a resort. I think a villa is going to be the answer but wanted to at least give them a choice. No all inclusives and no islands with danger alerts. I thought Antigua, Barbados, St. John or maybe Grand Cayman but having trouble finding what I am looking for. Any ideas of what might work - island, property, etc.?